If a customer bought something in your Black Friday sale and it arrived faulty, significantly different from the listing, or unsafe, Australian Consumer Law says they pick the remedy. Not you. They can demand their money back in the form they paid, and no line in your returns policy overrides that. Offering Shopify store credit instead of a refund is legal in Australia only for change-of-mind returns, which are the returns you were never obliged to accept in the first place. Get that distinction wrong on your policy page and you are one ACCC complaint away from a conversation you don't want.
Worth sorting out now, because the policy you publish before the sale is the one that governs January, and January is when change-of-mind volume actually lands. Gifts bought in late November get opened on 25 December. The returns arrive in the first fortnight of the new year, while you're still paying for the inventory you bought in September.
Two kinds of return, and only one of them is yours to design
Every return that walks in the door is one of two things.
The first is a consumer guarantee claim. The goods weren't of acceptable quality, didn't match the description, weren't fit for the purpose the customer told you about, or didn't arrive with the title or spare parts promised. These guarantees attach automatically to goods under $100,000, or to anything ordinarily bought for personal use regardless of price. They sit outside your policy, outside your warranty terms, and outside anything the customer clicked a checkbox on.
The second is change of mind. Wrong colour, didn't suit, bought two, found it cheaper elsewhere. Australian law gives the customer nothing here. You can refuse the return outright. You can also accept it on whatever terms you publish beforehand, including credit only.
Store credit belongs entirely in the second bucket. The trouble is that most returns software, and most BFCM advice, treats both as one flow with a credit-first default.
Major failure means the customer chooses the remedy
A problem is major when a reasonable person wouldn't have bought the item knowing about it, when the goods are substantially unfit for their normal purpose and can't be made fit easily, when they're a long way off the description or the sample, or when they're unsafe. In that case the customer picks: full refund, identical replacement, or keep the item and get compensation for the drop in value. You don't get to steer them toward an exchange.
For a minor problem, you choose. Repair, replace or refund, within a reasonable time. If the repair drags on, it stops being minor and the choice moves back to the customer. A zip that fails after three weeks is a minor problem. A zip that fails and then takes you six weeks to sort out is a major one.
And consumer guarantees don't expire when your warranty does. The test is what's reasonable given the price and the nature of the item. A $900 coffee machine that dies in month fourteen is still your problem, warranty card or not.
There is no online cooling-off period in Australia
This is the one that surprises merchants who read UK and EU returns advice. Australia has no general right to cancel an online order within 14 days. Cooling-off rights exist for unsolicited sales, telemarketing and door-to-door, not for someone who found you through a Meta ad and checked out voluntarily.
So a 30-day change-of-mind window is a commercial decision you made, not a legal obligation you inherited. Which means you set the terms. Which means credit-only is available to you, if you say so clearly before the sale.
Where store credit instead of a refund is legal, and how to say it
For change-of-mind returns you can offer credit only, exchange only, or nothing at all. You can require the item unworn with tags. You can require return postage at the customer's cost. You can impose a handling fee. All of it is fine, provided the terms are disclosed before purchase and the customer can actually find them.
What you cannot do is write anything that implies the guarantees don't apply. "No refunds." "Store credit only, no exceptions." "Sale items final." The ACCC treats blanket statements like these as misleading, because a customer with a faulty item reads them and walks away from a right they have. The fix is one sentence, not a rewrite:
Change-of-mind returns are offered as store credit within 30 days. This policy is in addition to your rights under the Australian Consumer Law, which include a refund, replacement or repair where goods are faulty or not as described.
Put it on the policy page, the returns portal landing page, and in the order confirmation email. Three places, same wording.
Restocking fees and who pays return postage
Restocking fees are legal in Australia for voluntary change-of-mind returns, as long as they're disclosed up front and genuinely reflect your cost rather than operating as a penalty. They are not legal when a consumer guarantee applies. You can't deduct 15% from a refund for a faulty item.
Same split on postage. Change of mind, the customer pays to send it back. Faulty goods, you wear the return cost, and if the item is bulky or heavy enough that returning it is a real burden, you're expected to collect it or pay for collection.
That second rule bites harder here than almost anywhere. A Sendle or Australia Post return leg from Kalgoorlie or Katherine on a 4kg item will clear $20 before you've touched it, and you can't pass it on. If you sell anything bulky into WA, NT or regional Queensland, model that cost into your faulty-return rate before you price the product, not after.
What store credit is actually worth, with the arithmetic
Credit is usually described as "retained revenue". It isn't. It's a deferred liability that costs you cost of goods when it's redeemed. The gain is real, but it's smaller than the headline.
Take a store doing 1,800 BFCM orders at a $118 average, so $212,400 across the weekend. Assume change of mind runs at 9% of orders with an average return value of $95. That's 162 returns and $15,390 at stake.
Now price one $100 return two ways, at 45% COGS.
- Cash refund: $100 out the door. Item comes back and goes on the shelf.
- Store credit: nothing out today. The customer later spends it on a $128 basket, topping up $28 in cash. You ship $128 of retail goods, costing you $57.60. Net cash movement: $28 in, $57.60 out, so $29.60 negative.
Difference per $100: $70.40 in your favour. If two thirds of the $15,390 goes to credit, that's $10,260 of credit, and $10,260 × 0.704 = roughly $7,220 of cash you keep in the business through January.
Real, but that model assumes every dollar of credit gets redeemed and ignores the inbound postage. Unredeemed credit looks better on cash flow and worse on the relationship, and it still sits on your balance sheet. Treat the $7,220 as the ceiling, not the forecast.
Setting up store credit in Shopify so it doesn't create tickets
Shopify has built-in store credit that sits on the customer profile, separate from gift cards. You issue it from the customer record in admin or via the API, and it applies at checkout when the customer is logged in. Gift cards are transferable codes that work for anyone holding them. That difference drives most of the setup decisions.
Four things we check on every returns build:
- Login requirement. Credit tied to a customer account is useless to a shopper who checked out as a guest and can't remember which email they used. If guest checkout is a meaningful share of your orders, test the recovery path before you promise anything.
- Expiry. Gift cards sold to consumers in Australia must be valid for at least three years with no post-purchase fees. Whether a credit note issued against a return sits inside those rules is an argument not worth having. Give it three years or no expiry.
- Automation. Shopify Flow can issue credit when a return is marked received, so your support team isn't doing it by hand at 11pm on 4 January. Build and test the flow in November, not in the middle of the rush.
- Currency. Credit is issued in one currency. If you run separate AUD and NZD markets, decide which one and tell the customer, or you'll be fielding emails about a balance that won't apply.
Shopify's native returns tools handle request, approval and label generation. They don't handle bonus-credit incentives, which is where apps like Return Prime, Loop or AfterShip earn their keep: offering, say, 10% extra when a customer takes credit instead of a refund. That's a legitimate offer for change-of-mind returns. Just don't bury or pre-select away the refund option when the customer has flagged a fault. Dark patterns in returns flows are exactly what the ACCC has been looking at, and a pre-ticked credit radio button is hard to defend.
Extending the window for a summer Christmas, and gift receipts
Extending the BFCM window to 31 January is the right call for most stores, for a boring reason: a gift bought on 28 November and opened on Christmas Day is already outside a standard 30-day policy. Refusing it is technically within your rights and will cost you the customer and the review.
Shopify has no native gift receipt. The workarounds that hold up: an order note or line-item property captured at checkout, a gift-message app, or simply accepting the order number from the recipient and issuing credit to a new customer account in their name. Whatever you choose, remember that a person who receives goods as a gift has the same consumer guarantee rights as the buyer. If the thing is faulty, the recipient can claim directly, and the fact that they didn't pay for it is irrelevant.
The trade-off on a longer window is cash timing, not return volume. You move returns from December into late January, which is the same fortnight your card settlements have already slowed down. Price that in.
Afterpay and Zip: refunds go back the way they came
Where a refund is owed, it goes to the original payment method unless the customer agrees otherwise. With buy-now-pay-later that isn't a formality, it's the whole mechanism. Process the refund through the original Shopify order and the BNPL provider adjusts the instalment schedule, cancelling what's outstanding and returning what's already been paid to the customer's card.
Hand that customer store credit instead and they keep paying Afterpay for an item they no longer own. For a change-of-mind return where credit is your published policy, that's legal and they agreed to it. It will still generate a support ticket and sometimes a dispute, so say it explicitly in the returns flow: your remaining instalments continue. For a consumer guarantee claim, credit isn't an option at all, because the customer is entitled to be put back where they started and only a refund through the original transaction does that.
One operational trap with extended windows. The refund button on an old order isn't live forever, and a late-January return against a 28 November order can land past the point where the original transaction is still refundable in one click. Check a sample old order in your admin before you publish the dates, and decide in advance whether you'll do a manual bank transfer or just eat it.
While you're there, sort the GST treatment with your accountant. A refund triggers an adjustment to the GST you've already remitted; store credit issued isn't a taxable supply until it's spent. Different BAS periods, different numbers.
Three questions we get asked every November
Can I keep credit-only for sale items? For change of mind, yes, if it's disclosed before purchase. For faulty goods, no. Discounted doesn't mean unguaranteed. The only sale item exception is a fault you specifically drew attention to and sold the item cheaper because of, like a marked second with a named flaw.
Does a customer need a receipt? You can ask for proof of purchase, and that's broader than a tax invoice. A bank or credit card statement, a lay-by agreement, a confirmation email or an order number in your admin all count.
Is a 20% restocking fee reasonable? Probably not, and more importantly it's the kind of number that reads as a penalty rather than a cost recovery. A flat fee tied to the actual return postage and handling is easier to defend and easier for customers to accept.
Give yourself an afternoon this week. Rewrite the policy page with the consumer guarantee line in it, set the credit expiry to three years, run one test return end to end through Afterpay, and check what a January-dated refund looks like against a November order. If you want someone to go through the returns flow with you before the weekend, our Australian Shopify team does this work, and a free audit will tell you where the flow breaks before your customers find out.
This is how we build returns flows for Australian stores, not legal advice. For anything contentious, check the ACCC's consumer guarantees material or talk to a lawyer.


